Classical Roots and Jazz Beginnings
Coleman was a child prodigy who shifted from classical to jazz, leading the popular Cy Coleman Trio in the New York club scene starting in 1948. He became known for a "bepoppy" jazz style and recorded numerous tracks, making a mark as both a pianist and composer in the jazz world.
Songwriting and Pop Collaborations
Early in his career, Coleman collaborated with lyricist Joseph Allen McCarthy. However, his most successful pop partnerships were with Carolyn Leigh. With Leigh, he created pop standards such as "Witchcraft" and "The Best Is Yet to Come," made famous by artists like Frank Sinatra. Another notable pop song by Coleman is "Firefly," which was recorded by Tony Bennett.
Broadway and Theater Success
Coleman transitioned to Broadway, where his compositions became iconic. His first major Broadway credit was Wildcat (1960), co-written with Carolyn Leigh and starring Lucille Ball. The production introduced the hit "Hey, Look Me Over". Additional Broadway successes include Little Me, Sweet Charity, Seesaw, and Barnum—all featuring memorable, enduring scores. Many of his songs, such as "Big Spender" and "I've Got Your Number," have become musical theater standards.
Influence and Legacy
Though jazz was his early passion, Coleman’s major cultural impact is tied to his role as a force in American pop music and Broadway. His work is more associated with these genres than with Jazz. Despite the inaccuracies in previous descriptions of his work, Coleman's contribution to music remains significant and his legacy continues to inspire artists today.